I mean, except for the last two Slams Federer has won, all of his majors were largely won due to his superior talent and skill. He was by far the better player at each one of them and deservedly held the trophy high on that Sunday.
The last two were not as pure in that respect. While you cannot fault Federer for his finalist clown to be green and awed by the occasion to the extent that his real game deserts him, it was nevertheless a clear departure from what had been the norm for Federer at every Slam.
Add to it the fact that on both occasions, the finalist at the last two US Opens eventually beat Federer the very next time they met, further strengthening the argument on how handcuffed they were on the big stage for their first time there.
Djokovic’s may have some mono BS spun into it but with Murray there appears no doubt where the rivalry is headed.
Although Djokovic never beat Federer after that AO semifinal, giving credence to the mono BS, but part of the reason was Djokovic’s own decline in focus and consistency evident from the fact that he failed to win a hard court title since March of last year. That TMC title was won more out of default than his own showing.
Translation: Evidence points to complete paralysis of both opponents in the final as a very possible reason Federer won No. 12 and 13, more than Federer’s superior skill and talent so conspicuously obvious in all of his other 11 Slams. Unable to duplicate that win on both right after that match up stands as a strong exhibit to prove the point.
But there’s nothing unique or alarming about the trend. Every great has gone through that phase to extend his career beyond the standard window to break the barrier between mortals and legends.
Kobe Bryant is at it now. He just won the MVP at the All-Star game yesterday despite Le Bron’s equally intense desire to win it for himself. You think Kobe is using his experience and greater understanding of the game to hold off a determined effort from a younger and extremely hungry Le Bron? You bet!!!!
But that intangible edge over a younger opponent can only take you so far. That bridge can extend only that much before youth and the hungrier mindset takes over.
However, with the way things have opened this season, Federer may have another huge advantage that may potentially determine ALL of his future Slam wins. Have a clue? No, you don’t!!!!
It’s the injuries that have plagued all three of his top adversaries. Nadal, Djokovic and Murray are all hurting so early in the season. Federer’s superior conditioning may turn into a weapon his talent and skill was once, to produce another streak of Slams just enough for him to sail past Sampras.
His talent alone now appears insufficient to consistently win over the upstarts. With No. 28 approaching and the field getting more experienced and seasoned, this may be the opening that can tilt the scales in Federer’s favor before the cats stabilise the ship.
Every great in any sport has won some of the big prizes this way. They themselves were surprised by the outcome, given how sup-bar their own performance was.
It’s called being lucky AFTER you have paid the dues or what do they say ‘Luck favors the one who works hard’ or something like that.
Federer should rally to convince ATP to move the other three Slams of the year to March. Does he really have to give a reason for it?
Injuries / illnesses to all three clowns are recurring ones, ones each has fought for sometime now opening the door for Federer just enough to finish his job.
Not getting to No. 14 for Federer is like Jordan never winning a championship. Everyone has unanimously acknowledged Federer as the greatest to ever pick up a racket, but if stats don’t stand behind that claim, specially the gold standard ones, the whole accolade loses its thunder.
With the other gold standard of most straight years as No 1. already toast, Federer needs this as badly as he once needed the Roland Garros title. He can then retire content and satisfied, despite the Roland Garros blot. If not, it will haunt him for the rest of his life, more than Lendl is haunted by his 11 Slam final defeats.